Skip to content
Photo 1 of 26
Photo 1 of 26 — 46 High Street, Edgartown, MA 02539
View all 26 photos

46 High Street, Edgartown, MA 02539

Dukes County

Key Facts

4Beds
5Baths
4,200Sq Ft
2009Year Built
0.11Lot (acres)
1Garage

Description

Located in Edgartown Village but on one of it's less traveled streets, this classic Greek Revival stands elegantly on tree lined High Street...It appears to be a beautifully restored historic home when in reality it is a newly constructed home that will march into the next two centuries and become it's own antique in the future...the design and interior furnishes follow in true traditional style with the contemporary benefit of numerous bathrooms, larger rooms, state of the art kitchen...the attached one car garage and large, finished lower level add to the functionality of this property. Current land and building assessment reflects 1/3 completion of new building.

Property Information

Property Type

Residential

Sub-Type

Single Family Residence

Year Built

2009

Living Area

4,200 sq ft

Lot Size

0.11 acres

Garage Spaces

1

Zoning

R-5

Days on Market

188

MLS® Listing#

21202784

Property Features

Exterior

Outdoor Shower

Appliances

Electric Water Heater

Cooling

Central Air

Heating

Forced Air

Flooring

CarpetTileWood

Basement

FinishedFull

Parking

Attached

Lot Features

On Golf CourseNear Golf CourseLevel

Construction

Clapboard

Foundation

Concrete Perimeter

Roof

ShingleWood

Financial Details

HOA

None

Annual Taxes

$5,729

Tax year 2011

Assessed Value

$1,339,200

Parcel Number

20C1972

Directions

Pease's Point Way South to High Street on the left. House is located on the right side of High Street.

Affordability Calculator

$477,000

Estimated monthly payment

$12,694/mo

Principal $1,908,000 · Est. interest $2,661,830 over 30 yrs

Neighborhood Market Statistics

How this home compares to active listings in Edgartown, MA

$1,000,000
Median Listing Price
63
Median Days on Market
2,742
Median Sq Ft
$1,300
Median Price / Sq Ft
42
Active Listings
  • This home’s price is 139% above the area median.
  • Its price per sq ft is 56% below the area median.

Market statistics compiled from active EXIT Realty® and MLS listings in Edgartown, MA.

Location

Map showing the location of 46 High Street, Edgartown, MA 02539

Getting Around

Walk
Bike

Somewhat Walkable

Walk Score details ↗

Points of Interest in Edgartown, MA

Showing the Edgartown area map.

Nearby Schools

  • The Edgartown School

    Elementary · 0.2 mi away

  • Martha's Vineyard Regional High School

    Secondary · 4.5 mi away

  • Oak Bluffs Elementary School

    Elementary · 4.8 mi away

  • Tisbury Elementary

    Elementary · 6.5 mi away

  • Martha's Vineyard Regional High School

    Secondary · 6.6 mi away

  • Vineyard Montessori School

    Elementary · 6.8 mi away

  • West Tisbury School

    Elementary · 7.5 mi away

  • Island Childrens School

    School · 7.6 mi away

  • Martha's Vineyard Public Charter School

    Secondary · 7.9 mi away

  • Chilmark Elementary

    Elementary · 12.1 mi away

  • Penikese Island School

    School · 12.1 mi away

  • Children's School of Science

    School · 12.3 mi away

  • Mullen Hall School

    School · 12.5 mi away

  • Village Science Playground

    Elementary · 12.5 mi away

  • Falmouth Community School

    School · 12.6 mi away

  • Lawrence School

    Secondary · 12.6 mi away

  • Morse Pond School

    Secondary · 12.7 mi away

  • Sandpiper Nursery School

    School · 13.0 mi away

  • Teaticket Park

    School · 13.0 mi away

  • Falmouth Public Schools - Massachusetts

    School · 13.2 mi away

Commute Calculator

Travel mode

Nearby Homes

Similar Homes Nearby

Similar Home Values

Comparable nearby listings and their asking prices.

AddressPriceBedsBathsSq Ft
18 Wood Duck Way, Edgartown, MA$1,800,000432,864
99 Old Purchase Road, Edgartown, MA$1,850,000432,064
7 Pip'n Circle, Edgartown, MA$2,195,000542,628
60 Crocker Drive, Edgartown, MA$2,300,000331,344
81 Whalers Walk, Edgartown, MA$2,325,000332,630
105 Whalers Walk, Edgartown, MA$2,395,000431,968

Moving Cost Estimate

EXIT Agents in Edgartown

Cape Cod and Islands MLS logo

Listing Courtesy: Sandpiper Realty Inc - 5086273737

Presented by: Elaine T Miller

The data relating to real estate for sale on this site comes from the Broker Reciprocity of the Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Summary or thumbnail real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than the brokerage firm owning this website are marked with the IDX Logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing broker nor the brokerage firm owning this website shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints and shall be held totally harmless. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright ©2026 Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Last Updated: 2012-03-26

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of one or more Multiple Listing Services (MLS). Listing information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate. Copyright © EXIT Realty® and respective MLS providers.

Data provided by CapeCod. MLS® Listing#21202784. © 2026EXIT Realty®. All rights reserved.